Yes, it's one of the more horrifying photographs you'll see for some time. The media was rightly all over it, criticizing the president for completely failing in his ending of the twenty year war. The piling onto President Biden was pretty much unanimous. And Biden responded that this was the right thing to do, history will show that, and that it never would have been an orderly evacuation. I now think he's right about that.
Initially I wondered why the evacuation did not begin in secret once it became clear that the Taliban, from a distance at first, was steadily working toward encircling Kabul. That was my criticism.
But think about that. What would have happened if Americans and their ancillary staff and Afghan allies just began disappearing in the night? Instantly it would have been noticed, and the rumors would have flown, with panic breaking out everywhere. I agree with Biden that it all would have happened anyway.
And those who say stay - STAY!? We were warned that Afghanistan is the graveyard of empires. Yet we came in with such hubris anyway. The military should have had an anthropology department. Scholars would have pointed out that cultures with roots thousands of years deep, will not likely transition to a modern democratization. No amount of money, no amount of weapons can do that. But we had to have our revenge, and I don't disagree with that. Once revenge was achieved however, we should have begun a withdrawal. I love Obama, but that was his mistake.
Eisenhower's warning about the military industrial complex was spot on. The military arms suppliers, support contractors, and providers of mercenaries surely made billions in profits during this twenty year period. It is certain that those companies leaned hard on congressional members and senators to keep the conflict going. Jobs, jobs, jobs. Money, money, money. Death, death, death.And now we have yet another full generation of military personnel, volunteers yet, who struggle with PTSD from doing their patriotic duty in a nightmare struggle in a land and culture so foreign that it could have been on another planet. All that time, money, misery, and death for just a few tangible positive outcomes.
Yes, we worry for those Afghan citizens who helped support our efforts. Even more, we are worried that the women of Afghanistan will once again become for all intents and purposes slaves under Sharia law.Since WWII the U.S. has self-identified as the savior of the world. But we are now only 4.2% of the people on this planet, and are as deeply divided as we've been in 156 years. In 2021 we need to focus inward to try and repair our country. Help other countries? Of course. Can we solve every problem across the globe with our might and our dollars? No we can't. We must see that reality and accept it.
Biden did the right thing for this exact time.